I remember reading this thread the other day, and a suggestion that was made, for either dungeondezigns.com, or bedroombondage.com both disappeared. Now I am not sure, who posted it, or why it was removed, but I will replace the suggestions.
I live in the midwest and have bought some super cheap gear at Farm and Fleet (tack gear). Also gotta love Lowe's for Hardware.
Check out the Better Built Bondage book for how to build your own toys.
Subspace - thanks for putting me onto this thread.
My old gear is gone and it's going to stay that way - so I'm buying all new.
I had ordered from extreme restraints and wasn't really all that happy. i ordered the worst and ankle restraints ball gag and so on. Honestly, I felt like it was novelty gear more then anything meant for serious long term use.
Yesterday I ordered from BDSMstore - hoping things get a little better. Let everyone know.
This place had some really great prices on plugs, and simple restraints. It's not a BDSM focused store but still has some really good things on sale. Look into it!
E-Bay is where I was going to buy my collar but in the end I went with a basic black leather one from a pet store that my master seems to like.