If I may ask, I assume that you encounter chafing after you've been wearing it for an extended period of time? If so, I hope that I am able to shed some light on this topic in general. Mistress Taryn keeps me permanently plugged... She has required me to have a butt plug inserted at all times for over three whole years now. (See one of my first threads on here, "Butt plug 24/7? advice needed plz!" for more info)
It has honestly been awhile since I last used that specific plug, although I always found the medium Doc Johnson "classic" butt plugs to be enjoyable as well as a great introductory tool for those working towards getting used to having something in the ass.
Glad to hear that you love wearing it- sounds like you're on your way to becoming a butt plug aficionado.
One solution is to make an investment in a higher quality butt plug, a comfortable butt plug harness, or both =P
I prefer silicone plugs myself and find it to be the most comfortable material for being inserted for extended lengths of time. I usually have to wear a medium-sized silicone plug (actually, Doc Johnson's "The Big End" to be specific) the majority of the time and it's kept securely inserted thanks to the leather butt plug harness Mistress Taryn locks on. Despite the base actually being larger than your butt plug, and the fact that I am unable to remove my plug without permission, I really don't get any irritation because of the "plug pouch" on my harness's rear strap. (Although I'd have to say that a larger silicone base would still be much more comfortable versus a smaller base made out of a stiffer material)
When you're making your next purchase, check out a site that offers a plethora of different shapes and sizes. I have used a few in the past that have offered good deals and secure shopping and if you'd like to know more about that just let me know.
Hope that helps,
Taryn's Slave